Patna Press
  • Home
  • Patna
  • Bihar
  • Politics
  • Campus Buzz
  • Crime
  • Nation
  • World
  • Infra
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • About us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Patna
  • Bihar
  • Politics
  • Campus Buzz
  • Crime
  • Nation
  • World
  • Infra
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • About us
No Result
View All Result
Patna Press
No Result
View All Result
Home Bihar

Seeing Wife in ‘Objectionable Position’ With Another Man Does Not Prove Adultery: Patna High Court

The court said being seen in an “objectionable position” is not the same as proving sexual intercourse, and dismissed the husband's divorce plea for lack of concrete evidence.

Reporter by Reporter
September 15, 2026
in Bihar, Patna
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Patna High Court divorce ruling
0
SHARES
49
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Patna: Merely seeing one’s wife in an “objectionable position” with another man does not, by itself, establish adultery or prove that the two had sexual intercourse, the Patna High Court has observed while dismissing a man’s plea seeking divorce.

A division bench comprising Justice Bibek Chaudhuri and Justice Rana Vikram Singh held that there is a significant legal distinction between being seen in an “objectionable position” and actually having sexual intercourse.

The court dismissed the husband’s petition on September 3, 2026, upholding the decision of the Madhubani Family Court, which had rejected his divorce plea.

What was the case?

The couple, from Samastipur and Madhubani respectively, married on July 2, 2006. They initially lived together and had a son in 2010.

According to the husband, their relationship subsequently deteriorated after he allegedly discovered his wife in an objectionable position with her brother-in-law, who was the husband of her elder sister.

The husband alleged that when he objected, his wife became hostile and subjected him to cruelty.

He further alleged that on March 30, 2013, his father-in-law arrived at their home with several people and took away his wife and household belongings in a vehicle. He claimed that his wife had remained separated from him since then.

On the basis of these allegations, the husband approached the Madhubani Family Court seeking divorce under Sections 13(1)(i) and 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, citing adultery and cruelty.

The wife denied having an extramarital relationship with her brother-in-law and described the allegation as fabricated. She also claimed that making such an allegation against her amounted to cruelty.

She told the court that a local panchayat had been held to resolve the marital dispute and that a settlement had been reached, but the husband did not honour it.

The wife further alleged in her written statement that her husband had once attempted to kill her by poisoning her, following which she left the matrimonial home.

The Madhubani Family Court, on April 4, 2024, rejected the husband’s divorce petition and accepted the wife’s defence.

The husband subsequently challenged the Family Court’s decision before the Patna High Court.

Why did the High Court reject the divorce plea?

While dismissing the petition, the High Court noted that being seen in an “objectionable position” and having sexual intercourse are not the same thing.

The bench observed that the husband had failed to produce concrete evidence of sexual intercourse between his wife and the alleged partner.

The court highlighted several factors:

  • Under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, a petitioner alleging adultery must establish that the spouse had sexual intercourse with another person after the marriage.
  • Although the husband claimed to have personally witnessed his wife in an objectionable position, he did not lodge a police complaint over the alleged incident.
  • Neither his parents nor any other relative supported the allegation.
  • Adultery is generally established through circumstantial evidence, since direct evidence of an extramarital sexual relationship is rarely available.
  • Mere suspicion or possibility is not sufficient, and an allegation made solely through the husband’s statement cannot, by itself, establish adultery.
  • The husband failed to establish that his wife had a sexual relationship with her brother-in-law.

The bench also noted that the husband’s allegations of cruelty were substantially linked to the alleged extramarital relationship. Since the adultery allegation itself was not proved, the court found the cruelty allegations to be vague and unsupported.

How can adultery be proved?

In its judgment, the Patna High Court referred to the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s 1985 decision in Hargovind Soni v. Ramdulhari, which discussed the difficulty of proving adultery in matrimonial disputes.

Courts generally rely on circumstances and other evidence that collectively point towards an adulterous relationship. The types of evidence that may become relevant include:

Circumstantial evidence: A series of circumstances or events that clearly point towards an extramarital relationship.

Birth of a child during a period when the husband had no sexual relationship with his wife: Such evidence may become significant if it is satisfactorily established that the child could only have been conceived through a sexual relationship with another man.

Sexually transmitted disease: Evidence that one spouse contracted a sexually transmitted infection that could not have been acquired from the other spouse may be relevant.

Admission: An admission by the accused spouse acknowledging the extramarital relationship can also constitute relevant evidence.

The court’s observation does not mean that adultery can never be proved without direct evidence. Rather, the surrounding circumstances must be sufficiently strong to establish the allegation according to the applicable legal standard.

What does the Hindu Marriage Act say about cruelty?

Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act recognises cruelty as a ground for divorce.

Cruelty can broadly involve physical as well as mental conduct.

Physical cruelty may include assault, causing bodily injury or threatening serious physical harm.

Mental cruelty can involve conduct that causes sustained mental distress or makes continuation of the marital relationship unreasonable. Depending on the facts of a case, courts have considered allegations such as deliberately filing false criminal cases, making false and humiliating accusations about a spouse’s character, repeated verbal abuse, persistent dowry harassment, unjustified prolonged refusal of marital relations, abandonment without reasonable cause and other conduct causing serious mental suffering.

However, whether particular conduct amounts to cruelty depends on the facts and evidence of each individual matrimonial dispute.

What the Patna High Court ruling means

The ruling underscores that an allegation of adultery cannot be established merely by showing that a spouse was seen with another person in circumstances that appear suspicious or inappropriate.

For a divorce claim based on adultery, the evidence must establish the legally relevant fact of a sexual relationship. In this case, the High Court found that the husband failed to provide sufficient evidence and therefore upheld the Family Court’s decision rejecting his divorce plea.

Tags: AdulteryDivorcePatna High Court

Related Posts

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment
Bihar

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

November 19, 2026
Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? New BPSSC Chairman And 1993-Batch IPS Officer
Bihar

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities

November 19, 2026
AI Generated Image: Gaya Junction Redevelopment: Rs 300 Crore Project To Bring Airport-Like Facilities
Bihar

Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned

November 19, 2026
Next Post
DPR Ready For Delhi-Patna High-Speed Rail Corridor, 865-Km Track Proposed

DPR Ready For Delhi-Patna High-Speed Rail Corridor, 865-Km Track Proposed

Bihar’s SH-58 To Get New Toll Plaza At Naugachia Zero Mile in Bhagalpur

Bihar’s SH-58 To Get New Toll Plaza At Naugachia Zero Mile in Bhagalpur

Representative image of rasgulla linked to the reported Gaya child death

Rasgulla Turns Fatal In Gaya: 8-Year-Old Boy Dies After Sweet Gets Stuck In Throat

Instagram

  • Senior IPS officer Jitendra Singh Gangwar has been appointed as the new chairman of the Bihar Police Subordinate Services Commission (BPSSC), with additional responsibility alongside his role as Director General of the Vigilance Investigation Bureau.

The appointment follows irregularities in the police sub-inspector recruitment examination, which was cancelled after an Economic Offences Unit investigation.

#BiharNews #PatnaNews #BPSSC #BiharPolice #JitendraSinghGangwar
  • Patna Traffic Police has announced road restrictions ahead of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s scheduled visit to Vaishali on November 21. Restrictions will begin at 10 pm on November 20, with heavy vehicles barred from selected routes near Kachchi Dargah.

Commuters can use Gandhi Setu, JP Setu and suggested alternative roads. Check the advisory and plan your journey in advance.

#PatnaNews #TrafficAdvisory #BiharNews #NarendraModi #Vaishali
  • Indian Railways has announced 13 post-Chhath special trains from Bihar to manage the passenger rush. The services will connect several Bihar stations with Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru, Ahmedabad, Udhna and other destinations between November 20 and 24.

Passengers are advised to check the latest timings on NTES or RailOne before travelling.

#BiharNews #IndianRailways #SpecialTrains #ChhathPuja #PatnaNews
  • Completing TB treatment does not always mean the lungs have fully recovered. An AIIMS Patna study published in BMJ Open found that 76.2% of participants continued to experience respiratory symptoms after treatment.

The findings highlight the importance of continued lung health monitoring and mental health support for TB survivors.

#AIIMSPatna #TBResearch #Tuberculosis #BiharNews #HealthAwareness
  • Chief Minister Samrat Choudhary has outlined Bihar
  • Bihar is planning to install 500 ANPR cameras across the state under its Intelligent Traffic Management System (ITMS) project. The initiative aims to improve traffic monitoring, strengthen electronic enforcement and support road safety.

The project will operate under a 10-year Public-Private Partnership model.

#BiharNews #PatnaNews #TrafficManagement #RoadSafety #ITMS
  • First Look Of Nitish Setu! 🌉

A spectacular view of Nitish Setu, the six-lane Kachchi Dargah-Bidupur bridge connecting Patna and Vaishali across the Ganga. Prime Minister Narendra Modi will inaugurate the bridge and dedicate it to the nation during his Bihar visit on November 21. A major boost to Bihar’s connectivity!
#Bihar #Patna #nitishSetu #NitishKumar #PatnaNews
  • The Directorate of Revenue Intelligence seized 4.525 kg of charas, estimated to be worth ₹4.525 crore, in Vaishali and arrested one man. According to the DRI, the consignment was allegedly smuggled from Nepal and intended for delivery in Pune. Further investigation is underway.

#BiharNews #Vaishali #DRI #DrugSeizure #NDPSAct
  • Passengers returning to other states after Chhath Puja can check vacant berths across several special trains operating from Bihar. Railway availability data recorded at 12 noon on November 19 showed 3,429 available seats and berths across Sleeper, AC and Chair Car categories for travel between November 20 and 30. Passengers are advised to check the latest availability before booking, as the figures may change.
#BiharRailways #ChhathPuja #SpecialTrains #TrainTicket #IndianRailways
BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

by Deepak Tiwari
November 19, 2026
0

BIADA has approved the allotment of 64.23 acres of industrial land and Plug & Play sheds to 33 industrial units,...

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? New BPSSC Chairman And 1993-Batch IPS Officer

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

The Bihar Government has appointed Jitendra Singh Gangwar as the new BPSSC chairman after irregularities were detected in the police...

AI Generated Image: Gaya Junction Redevelopment: Rs 300 Crore Project To Bring Airport-Like Facilities

Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

Gaya Junction is being upgraded at an estimated cost of Rs 300 crore to provide airport-like facilities. The arrival of...

Patna Traffic Advisory For PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit: Kachchi Dargah Route Restrictions

Patna Traffic Police Issues Route Advisory Ahead Of PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit, Kachchi Dargah Route To Face Restrictions From 10 PM

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

Patna Traffic Police has announced traffic restrictions and alternative routes ahead of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s November 21 programme in...

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment
Bihar

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

by Deepak Tiwari
November 19, 2026
0

BIADA has approved the allotment of 64.23 acres of industrial land and Plug & Play sheds to 33 industrial units,...

Read moreDetails
Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? New BPSSC Chairman And 1993-Batch IPS Officer

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities

November 19, 2026
AI Generated Image: Gaya Junction Redevelopment: Rs 300 Crore Project To Bring Airport-Like Facilities

Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned

November 19, 2026
Patna Traffic Advisory For PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit: Kachchi Dargah Route Restrictions

Patna Traffic Police Issues Route Advisory Ahead Of PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit, Kachchi Dargah Route To Face Restrictions From 10 PM

November 19, 2026
Indian Railways Announces 13 Post-Chhath Special Trains From Bihar

Indian Railways Announces 13 Post-Chhath Special Trains From Bihar To Mumbai, Delhi And Other Cities

November 19, 2026

Recent Posts

  • BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment
  • Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities
  • Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned
  • Patna Traffic Police Issues Route Advisory Ahead Of PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit, Kachchi Dargah Route To Face Restrictions From 10 PM
  • Indian Railways Announces 13 Post-Chhath Special Trains From Bihar To Mumbai, Delhi And Other Cities
BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment

by Deepak Tiwari
November 19, 2026
0

BIADA has approved the allotment of 64.23 acres of industrial land and Plug & Play sheds to 33 industrial units,...

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? New BPSSC Chairman And 1993-Batch IPS Officer

Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

The Bihar Government has appointed Jitendra Singh Gangwar as the new BPSSC chairman after irregularities were detected in the police...

AI Generated Image: Gaya Junction Redevelopment: Rs 300 Crore Project To Bring Airport-Like Facilities

Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

Gaya Junction is being upgraded at an estimated cost of Rs 300 crore to provide airport-like facilities. The arrival of...

Patna Traffic Advisory For PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit: Kachchi Dargah Route Restrictions

Patna Traffic Police Issues Route Advisory Ahead Of PM Modi’s Vaishali Visit, Kachchi Dargah Route To Face Restrictions From 10 PM

by Priyani Pandey
November 19, 2026
0

Patna Traffic Police has announced traffic restrictions and alternative routes ahead of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s November 21 programme in...

Recent News

  • BIADA Approves 64.23 Acres Of Industrial Land For 33 Units, Projects Rs 915 Crore Investment
  • Who Is Jitendra Singh Gangwar? Vigilance DG Takes Additional Charge As BPSSC Chairman Amid SI Exam Irregularities
  • Gaya Junction To Get Airport-Like Facilities Under Rs 300 Crore Redevelopment Plan, Better Security And World-Class Amenities Planned
  • Home
  • Patna
  • Bihar
  • Politics
  • Campus Buzz
  • Crime
  • Nation
  • World
  • Infra
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • About us

© 2026 PatnaPress.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Patna
  • Bihar
  • Politics
  • Campus Buzz
  • Crime
  • Nation
  • World
  • Infra
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • About us

© 2026 PatnaPress.com