Patna: The Patna High Court has imposed an interim restraint on media coverage in the high-profile Rishu Shree case, directing print, electronic, digital and social media platforms not to portray the petitioner as guilty while criminal proceedings remain pending.
The interim order was passed by a single-judge bench of Justice Ansul, which observed that a fair trial is a constitutional right and should not be prejudiced by speculative or sensational reporting.
Court Restrains Prejudicial Reporting
In its order, the High Court clarified that media organisations remain free to report factual developments relating to the investigation and judicial proceedings.
However, the court said reporting must not include speculative or prejudicial content that suggests the accused’s criminal culpability before the conclusion of the trial.
The order applies not only to traditional news organisations but also to online news portals, podcasts, video-streaming platforms and social media channels.
Labels Suggesting Guilt Barred
The court specifically observed that it would be inappropriate for media platforms to describe the petitioner using terms such as “mastermind”, “kingpin”, “scamster” or similar expressions before a judicial determination of guilt.
According to the bench, such descriptions create an impression that the accused has already been found guilty, potentially influencing public opinion and undermining the fairness of the judicial process.
Fair Trial A Constitutional Right
During the hearing, the court referred to several Supreme Court judgments addressing media trials and the need for judicial intervention where reporting risks affecting ongoing criminal proceedings.
Justice Ansul observed that irresponsible or sensational reporting has the potential to influence the administration of justice and compromise an accused person’s right to a fair trial.
The court emphasised that while freedom of the press remains an essential constitutional value, it must be balanced against the equally fundamental principle of ensuring impartial judicial proceedings.
Next Hearing In July
The interim directions will remain in force while the matter is under consideration.
The High Court has listed the case for its next hearing on 10 July 2026, when it is expected to consider the matter further.
The order adds to a series of judicial pronouncements highlighting the need for responsible reporting in ongoing criminal cases and reaffirming the principle that an accused person is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
